Torsion vs. Extension Springs: Which Is Best for Your Garage?
When your garage door system fails, or if you are planning a new installation, you are faced with a critical mechanical choice: torsion springs or extension springs. While both serve the same fundamental purpose—counterbalancing the weight of the door so it can be lifted easily—they operate in vastly different ways.
Choosing the right system affects the safety, longevity, and maintenance requirements of your home. To help you make an informed decision, let’s look at the mechanics, benefits, and drawbacks of each system.
What Are Torsion Springs?
Torsion springs are the modern standard for residential garage doors. They are located on a metal shaft (the torsion bar) directly above the door opening. Instead of stretching, these springs function by twisting and coiling. When the door is lowered, cables attached to the bottom corners pull on drums, which winds the spring and stores energy.
The Benefits
Superior Balance: Torsion springs provide a more controlled and steady motion. This balance reduces the strain on your garage door opener, extending the life of the motor.
Increased Durability: These springs are typically rated for 10,000 to 20,000 cycles. Because they don't stretch to their physical limits, they tend to last significantly longer than extension alternatives.
Enhanced Safety: When a torsion spring breaks, it stays on the shaft. You might hear a loud pop, but the spring does not fly off and cause damage to your car or bystanders.
Smoother Operation: Because the weight is distributed more evenly across the shaft, the door opens and closes with less jerking and noise.
The Drawbacks
Higher Initial Cost: Torsion systems involve more components (shafts, drums, bearings) and are generally more expensive to install.
Expert Installation Required: Due to the extreme torque involved, these should only be adjusted or replaced by trained professionals.
What Are Extension Springs?
Extension springs are the traditional option often found in older homes or garages with limited overhead space. These springs are mounted horizontally above the tracks on both sides of the door. They function by stretching (extending) as the door closes and contracting to provide lifting power as it opens.
The Benefits
Cost-Effective: The parts for an extension system are simpler and cheaper than torsion setups. If you are on a strict budget, this is the most economical entry point.
Space-Saving: For garages with very low ceilings where a torsion shaft won't fit, extension springs are often the only viable solution.
The Drawbacks
Safety Risks: These springs act like giant rubber bands. If they snap without a safety cable installed through the center, they can become dangerous projectiles.
More Parts to Wear Out: Because extension springs move independently on each side, the door can easily become unbalanced. This puts uneven pressure on the tracks and rollers.
Shorter Lifespan: Most extension springs are only rated for about 5,000 to 10,000 cycles, meaning you will be replacing them much more frequently.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Feature | Torsion Springs | Extension Springs |
| Location | Above the door on a rod | Parallel to the horizontal tracks |
| Motion | Twisting (Torque) | Stretching (Extension) |
| Expected Life | 8–15 years | 4–7 years |
| Safety | High (contained on shaft) | Lower (requires safety cables) |
| Maintenance | Low | Moderate |
| Best For | Heavy doors & daily use | Small budgets & low ceilings |
Making the Right Choice for Your Home
If your garage has the necessary "headroom" (the space between the top of the door and the ceiling), torsion springs are almost always the better investment. The increased safety and the fact that they last twice as long as extension springs make them more cost-effective over time. They provide a quieter, more reliable experience that protects the rest of your garage door hardware.
However, if you have a very light, single-car door and rarely use the garage, or if your ceiling height is extremely restricted, extension springs remain a functional and affordable choice.
Regardless of which system you choose, the key to a long-lasting garage door is regular lubrication and professional inspection. Ensuring your springs are correctly matched to the weight of your door is the single most important factor in keeping your home’s largest moving part operating safely.
The Ultimate Guide to Fixing a Garage Door Spring Safely and Effectively